My Best Friend’s Daughter

Unlock Every Secret Path in This Thrilling Choice-Based Adventure

Ever stumbled upon My Best Friend’s Daughter and felt that rush of forbidden excitement? This choice-based game pulls you into a web of tempting decisions with your best friend’s family, where every pick shapes steamy encounters and hidden desires. I remember my first playthrough—nailing those early choices with Natali had me hooked for hours, unlocking scenes I didn’t know existed. Whether you’re chasing Tom’s path or exploring Elle’s trust dynamics, this guide shares my personal strategies to conquer the game. Dive in to master interactions, boost desire levels, and hit every optimal outcome without missing a beat.

How to Master Choices in My Best Friend’s Daughter

Alright, let’s get straight into it. If you’re here, you’ve probably hit a wall in My Best Friend’s Daughter. Maybe you got a weird ending, or you’re staring at the screen wondering why Natali is giving you the cold shoulder or why Elle won’t open up. I’ve been there! 😅 This game is a masterpiece of branching narratives, but one wrong choice can send you down a totally boring path. This guide is all about sharing the hard-earned secrets from my many, many playthroughs, so you can unlock every thrilling scene and avoid my mistakes.

Think of this not just as a My Best Friend’s Daughter walkthrough, but as a chat with a buddy who’s obsessed with finding every hidden detail. We’re going to break down the crucial early moves, the pivotal moments with the girls, and how to set yourself up for the most rewarding—and steamiest—paths the game has to offer. Let’s dive in!

What Are the Best Early Game Decisions?

The foundation for everything in My Best Friend’s Daughter is laid in the first few days. You’re not just choosing dialogue; you’re building invisible meters—desire for Natali and trust for Elle. Mess this up, and you’ll be locked out of the good stuff later. I learned this the hard way on my first run.

I played it “safe,” trying to be the nice, neutral guy. Big mistake! 🚫 By Day 7, my interactions with Natali were super bland, and Elle was just politely distant. I had to restart completely. The game rewards boldness and attention.

So, here’s the golden rule from Day 1: Focus on one primary path per playthrough. The game’s structure really supports replaying to see everything. For your first serious run, I highly recommend focusing entirely on unlocking the Tom Natali path. It has the most intricate and rewarding storyline, in my opinion.

Your first major test comes with Elle’s broken phone. This is a critical Elle trust scene. You have two main options: fix it properly without snooping, or take a peek at her photos.

My Pro Tip: If you’re aiming for Elle’s good path, do NOT peek. Fix it honestly. This builds genuine trust and is essential for her more vulnerable scenes later. Peeking might give you a quick thrill and an alternate scene, but it damages your long-term potential with her and can affect how other characters perceive you. Save that for a curiosity replay!

The early days are about consistent characterization. Be confident and a little flirtatious with Natali when Tom isn’t right there, and be a supportive, reliable friend to Elle. This sets the stage for the two big turning points that come soon after.

Unlocking Natali’s Desire Path: My Top Tips

This is where the magic happens. 🎭 Natali’s route is all about building tension and desire. It’s a slow burn, and the key is to seize every opportunity to create a spark. The single most important set of optimal Day 4 decisions revolves around a seemingly simple event: bumping into her.

On Day 4, you’ll have the chance to either carefully avoid Natali or “accidentally” bump into her. In my failed run, I avoided it, thinking it was the polite thing to do. The result? Our connection felt weak, and later scenes lacked that electric charge.

On my next try, I went for the bump. Wow, what a difference! The physical contact, the slightly awkward but charged moment—it gives her desire a significant boost compared to the safer option. This one choice is a major accelerator for the Natali desire path.

But the real test comes on Day 7. You’ll be in a private moment with Natali, and you’ll be presented with the infamous Day 7 finger choice. This is non-negotiable. You must choose to use your finger if you want to progress her path meaningfully. Choosing to do nothing is essentially rejecting the advance and will stall the relationship. This specific choice is the key that unlocks her more intimate paths later, including the coveted “ass path” options.

To make it super clear, here’s how these two pivotal choices stack up:

Stick to the left column in that table, and you’re golden for Natali’s route. 😉 A fun insider note: if you’re on the right path, you’ll eventually trigger a sex dream about Natali that Tom witnesses—a brilliantly awkward and hilarious story beat that proves you’re on the right track!

Navigating Elle’s Trust Scenes Like a Pro

While Natali’s path is about desire, Elle’s is an emotional journey built on trust. Her Elle trust scenes are quieter but equally impactful. Your role here is to be her rock, not a predator. This path is incredibly satisfying if you enjoy emotional storytelling.

We already talked about the phone. Another key moment is listening to her problems without immediately trying to “fix” them or turning the conversation to yourself. Just be present. She’s dealing with her own insecurities, often highlighted by her friend Lex’s wild stories (fun fact: the devs have said Lex’s infamous “big dick” talk was inspired by overheard real-life locker room bragging! 😂).

The payoff for building Elle’s trust comes later, especially around Day 14. The conversation you have here diverges wildly based on your primary path.
* If you’ve focused on unlocking the Tom Natali path, you’ll likely start Day 14 at home with Natali, dealing with the consequences and tensions of your growing relationship.
* If you’ve built high trust with Elle, you’ll have a deep, heartfelt chat with Tom about Elle. This scene is beautiful and adds so much layers to everyone involved.

You can’t max out both paths simultaneously in one run—the game is designed to make you choose, which is what makes replaying so much fun. Elle’s path offers a sweeter, more romantic conclusion, while Natali’s is passionate and complicated.

Remember, mastering My Best Friend’s Daughter choices is all about intention and experimentation. Use multiple saves, track your progress, and don’t be afraid to reload and try a different option to see where it leads. The game is packed with secrets waiting to be found.

Now, here are my absolute must-follow pro tips to put this all into practice:

• Save Strategically: Before every major choice or new day. Title your saves clearly (e.g., “Day4_PreBump”, “Day7_PreFinger”) so you can branch out easily without restarting.
• Play in Character Order: For a cohesive story, complete a full run focusing on one character (e.g., Natali) before starting a new run for another (Elle or others). This lets you see a complete narrative arc.
• Embrace Replay: The game is designed for it. After your first “ideal” run, go back to key scenes and pick the “wrong” option just to see the different dialogues and alternate scenes—some are surprisingly revealing!
• Watch for Meter Cues: While not shown explicitly, pay close attention to character reactions. Blushing, smile intensity, and dialogue tone are your best indicators of whether your desire or trust is increasing.
• Don’t Rush the Day 7 Choice: When you get to the Day 7 finger choice, pause. This is the point of no return for locking in Natali’s path. Ensure you’ve made the supporting choices (like the Day 4 bump) to make this moment count.

Wrapping up my journey through My Best Friend’s Daughter, I’ve shared the choices that turned casual plays into unforgettable adventures—like that pivotal bump with Natali or building Elle’s trust step by step. These strategies helped me unlock deeper paths and hotter interactions, making every replay rewarding. If you’re just starting, grab those optimal picks and dive in; your next session will feel epic. Share your wildest outcomes in the comments—what path are you chasing next? Jump back in and make those bold moves today!